A live concert in support of a live record is where a band bloom like madness in the spring.
It's a bit of a paradox. When a touring band can have a well-deserved downtime if not after the release of a live album? But then, what's the best way to promote such a record if not going on stage and pulling all the stops? For JETHRO TULL, there was no question, though, for as fine as their studio works are, it's before the audience that the ensemble really exist. "Bursting Out", commited to tape in May and June 1978 and released in September, remains one of the best concert documents of rock era yet, while representing the band's show, it takes in the best performances from several nights, whereas this CD comes from a single New York matinee played in October. Which means, it's rougher - even more so, because that Madison Square Garden gig was broadcast overseas in real time and, thus, fraught with logictic difficulties. Still, tightly edited and stripped of the visuals preserved on the accompanying DVD, it makes for a gripping listen.
What suprises the most here is how heavy the group, first and foremost associated with the flute, are in the guitar department. Not only the razor-sharp "Aqualung" but also the opener, "Sweet Dream", chugs under Ian Anderson's belligerent voice on a roll of Martin Barre's pounding riff and a piquant sprinkling of John Evan's piano. Yet then, with no detriment to the weight, these instruments change position in the finishing salvo of "Locomotive Breath", driven by the keyboards and supported with the six-string safety net. Sometimes it's even twelve-string, if you count the leader's acoustic in the folk passages, be it the always-fantastic "Thick As A Brick" with its majestic baroque - and, finally, the first flute solo spot, twenty minute into the show - or the pastoral lull of "One Brown Mouse". And while "No Lullaby" may sound a bit flat, Tony Williams' bass puts a spice in it, and the master class in a reed-singing technique including "God Rest You, Merry Gentlemen" makes the piece a clarion call to action.
On with the action, all the broadcasting turmoil notwithstanding, everything's marked with elegance here, especially "Heavy Horses" - lighter than usual, it nods towards the disco times with a brilliant Barriemore Barlow's drumming that ranges from four-on-the-floor beat to the jig and the cymbals rustle - and the ensemble harmonies of "Songs From The Wood". But to end it all with an anthemic "Too Old To Rock 'n' Roll, Too Young To Die" would be too elegant and pretentious for JETHRO TULL, what with the preceding craziness of "Dambusters March", so with the skew coupling of "My God" and "Cross-Eyed Mary" the band bow out in style they have rarely demonstrated ever since, which makes this album a unique document.
****4/5